This discussion has popped up a lot lately; I suspect it has something to do with the misguided idea that the American experience will be different from top to bottom with the election of a Black man. This article http://black vs. african american in particular was cause for dismay. I wonder if the author sees the irony of writing about a lack of connection to Africa, on a website entitled The Root.com. What does she think she's rooted to? [Sigh]
I like Black. I think there's something powerful in taking what was a derogatory term and making it a rebellious statement of us as a people i.e. Black Power, Black and Proud, Black Panther.
But, it is Africa that binds us, not the shared experience of slavery. It is the origin of the innate qualities we share. Slavery didn't make us a people able to survive in the harshest conditions. Slavery didn't create revolutionaries, thinkers, artists and mc's. Nor did slavery create such strong, intelligent, beautiful women.
Slavery tested what God blessed us with, as Africans.